No other antique material dates itself as precisely as British silver. A date letter identifies the exact assay year, which means a hallmarked piece can be placed to a single twelve month period rather than a decade. That precision depends entirely on reading the letter in the right order, and most mistakes come from skipping a step.
What is a date letter?
A single letter of the alphabet struck in a shaped shield, changed annually by each assay office to record the year a piece was tested. It was introduced so that responsibility for a faulty assay could be traced to the year and the officer concerned.
The letter is not a code for anything and has no meaning in itself. It is simply the next letter in a sequence, and the sequence is documented office by office in published tables.
Why must you identify the town first?
Because each office ran its own alphabet on its own cycle, and they were never synchronised. The same letter in the same style means different years in different towns.
Read the town mark first, establish the office, then open the table for that office and only then look up the letter. Get this order wrong and you will produce a plausible looking date that is wrong by decades. This is the single most common error in reading a hallmark.
Why does the shield shape matter?
Because each office ran through an alphabet and then began again, so the same letter recurs every twenty or so years. What distinguishes one cycle from the next is the typeface of the letter and the shape of the shield around it.
Record whether the shield is a plain rectangle, has clipped corners, is shaped, pointed or a cartouche. Note whether the letter is a capital or lower case, and whether it is roman, italic or gothic. That combination is unique; the letter alone is not.
Which letters were omitted?
Several, and knowing that prevents confusion. Offices generally omitted J to avoid confusion with I, and most stopped short of the full alphabet, ending the cycle at U or V or thereabouts.
So a cycle typically runs twenty years rather than twenty six. Do not expect to find every letter, and do not assume a missing letter means anything unusual. The tables show exactly which letters each office used in each cycle.
Does the assay year match the calendar year?
Not exactly, which catches people out. Each office changed its letter on a fixed date in the year rather than on the first of January, so a single letter spans parts of two calendar years.
That means a piece marked with one letter could have been assayed in either of two calendar years depending on the month. For most purposes the approximation is fine, and published tables state the changeover date for each office if precision matters.
What if the letter is worn?
Work from what survives. Even a partial letter combined with a legible shield shape frequently narrows things to a single candidate within a known cycle.
Photograph under raking light from several angles rather than reading directly, and check whether the mark is repeated elsewhere on the piece, since lids, handles and detachable parts often carry their own marks and one may be clearer. Never polish the area to improve legibility, since that removes the dark residue making the letter visible.
Does the date letter prove age on its own?
It proves when the metal was assayed, which is almost always when the piece was made, but be careful about two situations. Marks can be transposed from an older item into a newer one, and modern silver carries date letters too.
Check that the form, decoration and construction of the object are consistent with the year the letter gives. Where a shape that belongs to one period carries a mark from a much earlier one, examine the marks closely for a seam around an inserted panel before accepting the date.