A marriage is the most confusing problem in antiques, because nothing about it is fake. Both parts are usually genuinely old, both may be good quality, and neither was made to deceive anybody. They simply never belonged together, and the combined object is worth considerably less than either component would be as part of a complete original.
Why are marriages made at all?
Because the parts are worth more together than apart. A bookcase top whose base has been lost is nearly unsaleable on its own, and so is a bureau whose top has gone. Joining them creates a complete looking piece with a buyer.
Much of this was done a long time ago and often without any intent to defraud, since a workshop reuniting orphaned components was performing a practical service. The problem arises only when the result is later sold as an untouched original.
Which pieces are married most often?
Anything made in two sections. Bureau bookcases, chests on chests, chests on stands, cabinets on stands and dressers with rack tops are all candidates, because the two halves separate easily and survive independently.
Clocks are the other major category, where a good movement is fitted into a case built for a different one. Mirrors, where old plate is fitted into a later frame or a good frame receives a new mirror, are a variation on the same theme.
Where should you look first?
At the join. Stand back and check the proportions: the base of a two part piece should be wider and deeper than the top by a sensible margin, so the top sits comfortably within it rather than overhanging or floating in the middle.
Then look at whether the mouldings align. On an original the moulding on the base was designed to receive the top, so they meet cleanly. A top sitting on a base that was not made for it usually shows gaps, a moulding that has been cut down, or packing pieces added to make the fit work.
What should you compare between the two halves?
Timber, colour, patina and construction quality, on unpolished surfaces rather than polished ones. Pull out a drawer from each half and compare the linings side by side.
The dovetails should be cut in the same manner, the secondary timbers should be the same species, and the colour of the oxidised interior should match. A difference in any of these across the join is a strong indicator. Also compare handle styles and the pattern of filled holes, since original pieces went through fashion changes together.
How do you spot a married clock?
By checking the seatboard, which is the wooden platform the movement rests on inside the case. It should show wear and fixing marks corresponding exactly to the movement sitting on it.
Extra holes, packing under the movement feet, or a seatboard that has been cut down or built up all indicate a different movement once sat there. Check the dial fills the hood aperture cleanly, since a gap around the edge or an enlarged opening means dial and case were not made for each other.
How much does a marriage reduce value?
Substantially, often by more than half compared with an original complete piece. The market pays for originality, and a marriage fails that test however good the individual parts are.
It is not worthless, and a well matched marriage of two good period components can be an attractive and useful object at the right price. What matters is that the price reflects what it is rather than what it appears to be.
What should you ask a seller?
Whether the two parts are original to each other, and ask for the answer written on the receipt. Reputable dealers disclose marriages as a matter of routine, since it is a recognised trade category rather than an accusation.
Terms such as associated, of the period but not original to, and later united all describe the same situation in catalogue language. If you see any of them, read on carefully. If a description is silent on a two part piece, look at the join yourself before committing.