Making something look older than it is has been a trade in its own right for a very long time, and the techniques are well established. Fortunately they all share one weakness. Genuine age is the product of a specific object being used by specific people in specific ways, and that produces a pattern no workshop can convincingly invent in an afternoon.
What does genuine wear actually look like?
Logical. It appears exactly where hands, feet, sleeves, cloths and other objects made contact, and it is entirely absent everywhere else. A chair arm wears where a palm rests. A drawer runner wears on its underside and develops a dip. A table edge wears where people leaned against it.
The wear also has depth and gradation, fading gradually from the point of heaviest contact rather than stopping abruptly. Before examining anything closely, ask yourself how a person actually using this object would have handled it, then check whether the wear tells that story.
How is wear faked?
Usually with abrasives, chains, gravel or wire brushes, and almost always too evenly. A distressed surface produced in a workshop tends to show marks of similar depth spread across the whole piece rather than concentrated where use would have put them.
Look for dents that are all roughly the same size, scratches running predominantly in one direction, and damage in places nobody could reach in normal use. Wear on the underside of a stretcher where feet rested is convincing. Uniform distressing across an entire top, including the middle where nothing ever touched, is not.
How is patina forced?
With stains, dyes, chemicals and heat, applied to darken a surface quickly. The result almost always sits on top of the timber rather than in it, because genuine patina develops from within as the wood oxidises over decades.
Check the difference between exposed and unexposed surfaces. On a genuine piece, the outside of a drawer front is markedly darker than the inside, and the back of a carcass is darker than its interior, with the change developing gradually. Forced colouring tends to be uniform throughout, including inside, or to show a hard edge where the application stopped.
What about fake worm holes?
These are among the easiest fakes to detect and among the most commonly attempted. Genuine woodworm larvae tunnel through timber in irregular winding paths, so a real hole is the end of a meandering tunnel that changes direction.
Faked holes are usually made with a drill or a fine pin, so they run straight into the surface at a consistent angle and to a consistent depth. Break a piece of scrap or look at any exposed section and see whether the tunnel wanders. Holes appearing in a regular scatter, or clustered in a decorative area rather than in sapwood where worm actually feeds, are a strong warning.
Are chemical treatments used on metal?
Frequently. Brass and copper can be darkened chemically in minutes to imitate decades of patina, and the result is usually flatter and more uniform than the real thing.
Genuine patina on copper alloys varies across the surface, staying brighter where hands touched and going darker in recesses, and it has depth rather than sitting on the metal like a coating. Artificial darkening often rubs off unevenly on a cloth, and it frequently reaches into places that handling would have kept bright.
What about smoke and dirt?
Deposits of grime are easy to add and easy to detect, because real dirt accumulates according to gravity and airflow. It settles on upward facing surfaces, gathers in the angles of mouldings and is thicker along the tops of horizontal members.
Applied dirt tends to appear on vertical faces and in places where nothing would ever settle. Run a finger along the top edge of a moulding and then along its underside. A genuine difference between the two is reassuring, and equal deposits everywhere are not.
What is the most reliable overall test?
Consistency across several independent kinds of evidence. Any one indicator can be explained away, since repairs, cleaning and restoration are all normal on genuinely old objects.
What you are looking for is agreement. Check the construction, the fixings, the tool marks, the timber colour and the wear pattern, and see whether they tell the same story. Four indicators pointing at one period with one anomaly usually means a repair. Evidence scattering in every direction usually means the object has been assembled or improved.