Every piece of timber in an antique was cut from a tree by a saw, and the saw left marks. On the surfaces the maker finished, those marks were planed away. On the surfaces nobody would ever see, they survive exactly as the tool left them, and they carry a date.
Where do you look for saw marks?
The parts nobody bothered with. The back of a carcass, the underside of a drawer bottom, the inside of a plinth, the top of a cornice, the underside of a table top and the hidden faces of any structural member.
Use a torch held at a shallow angle so the light rakes across the surface, because saw marks are shallow and disappear under direct light. Run a hand over the timber as well, since the ridges are often easier to feel than to see.
What do straight saw marks mean?
Hand or reciprocating sawing. A saw moving back and forth in a straight line leaves parallel marks running across the board, and because a human operator could not maintain a perfectly consistent stroke, those lines vary slightly in spacing and depth.
Early timber was frequently cut by two men working a long saw over a pit, one above and one below. That method leaves straight marks that sometimes wander slightly where the cut drifted. Mechanised reciprocating saws produce straighter and more regular parallel marks, but still straight.
What do circular arcs indicate?
A circular saw, and that is a firm ceiling on how early a piece can be. A rotating blade leaves curved arcs across the timber, and no hand tool can produce them.
The arcs are unmistakable once seen, appearing as a series of shallow curves running in the same direction. Their radius indicates the size of the blade. Finding circular saw marks anywhere on original untouched timber means the piece cannot predate mechanised sawing, whatever its style suggests.
Do straight marks prove great age?
No, and this is the important limitation. Hand sawing continued in country workshops long after circular saws arrived in industrial mills, so straight marks give you an earliest possible date rather than a latest one.
Timber was also reused. A workshop rebuilding a piece might incorporate older boards, so a single hand sawn component in an otherwise machine cut piece proves very little. Look for consistency across the whole object rather than deciding on one surface.
What do plane marks tell you?
How the surface was finished. A hand plane leaves very shallow scallops across the timber, visible in raking light as a series of faint ripples running at a slight angle to the grain.
These are subtle and easily missed, and they indicate hand finishing rather than machine planing, which produces a series of fine regular ridges from a rotating cutter block. Look for hand plane scallops on the interior faces of drawer sides and on the underside of tops.
How does the grain itself carry evidence?
Through shrinkage. Timber shrinks across the grain and barely at all along it, so a solid circular top slowly becomes slightly oval and a turned column becomes marginally out of round.
Measure across the grain and along it on any circular element. A genuine old solid top should differ measurably. Panels shrink within their frames, leaving a narrow strip of unfaded timber at the edge where the panel has pulled away from the moulding, and that strip is excellent evidence of long slow movement.
How should you weigh all this?
As one strand among several. Tool marks are strong evidence and they are hard to fake convincingly, but repairs, replaced components and reused timber all complicate the picture on genuinely old furniture.
Combine saw marks with the fixings, the joints, the timber colour and the wear pattern, and look for a story that agrees across all of them. Where four indicators point at one period and one does not, the odd one out is usually a repair rather than a verdict on the whole piece.