Back to Valuations

How to Avoid Scams When Selling Antiques

How to Avoid Scams When Selling Antiques
Antique Guides Editorial 18 May 2026

Selling antiques exposes you to a handful of well established problems, most of which rely on haste, flattery or the assumption that a stranger is who they say they are. None of them are sophisticated, and almost all of them fail against the same simple precautions applied consistently.

What should you make of unsolicited approaches?

Be cautious, always. Letters, cards through the door, cold calls and callers offering cash for antiques are a recognised pattern, and the entire model depends on buying below value from people who have not checked.

A legitimate buyer will not mind you seeking other opinions and will not pressure you to decide today. Anyone who insists the offer is only available now, or who discourages you from consulting anyone, is telling you something useful about the offer.

Why is valuing and buying in one visit a problem?

Because the two roles conflict directly. Someone who would like to own your item has an obvious interest in the figure they give you, and that is true even when they are perfectly pleasant about it.

Get valuations from people who charge a fee and have no interest in acquiring anything, then sell separately. For probate, insurance or dividing an estate you need that independence anyway, since a free verbal figure from an interested party will not satisfy an insurer or a tax authority.

What precautions should you take with callers?

Never let anyone into your home alone, and never let an item leave without a signed receipt describing it in detail with the agreed price. Photograph everything before it goes.

Be wary of anyone who asks to see other items once inside, or who wanders through rooms. Do not confirm what else you own or where it is kept. If a caller is persistent or you feel uneasy, end the conversation and close the door rather than negotiating.

What payment problems arise?

Reversible payments are the main one. Some payment methods allow a buyer to reclaim funds after receiving goods, leaving the seller with neither. Cheques can bounce well after they appear to have cleared.

Wait until funds are genuinely and irreversibly in your account before releasing anything. Be extremely wary of overpayment stories, where a buyer sends too much and asks you to refund the difference, which is a long established fraud and the refund is always real while the original payment is not.

What about courier and shipping tricks?

A common approach is a buyer who insists on sending their own courier, frequently for a high value item, sometimes with an urgent story attached. Once the goods are collected they are gone and the payment fails.

Use your own carrier, insured and tracked, and only after payment has cleared. Photograph the item at every stage of packing, since damage claims are routinely refused on the grounds of inadequate packing and the images are your evidence.

How do you handle meeting a buyer in person?

In daylight, with somebody else present, and preferably not at your home for a first meeting. For furniture that must be collected, arrange for a friend or family member to be there.

Take payment before the item is loaded, not afterwards. Do not accept part payment with a promise to settle later, and do not let goods leave on the understanding that the buyer will pay once they have checked something. Keep a written record of who bought what, for how much and when.

What paperwork protects you?

A receipt describing the item, its condition and the price, signed by both parties and dated. Keep a copy with photographs of the object taken before it left.

If you consign to a saleroom, get a signed inventory before anything is collected and read the terms on commission, fees, unsold lots and insurance while in their care. Documentation costs nothing and settles almost every dispute that arises afterwards.

What is the single best precaution?

Never deciding quickly. Almost every problem in this area depends on haste, and a buyer who genuinely wants your item will still want it next week.