Back to Valuations

Why Restoration Costs Should Set What You Pay

Why Restoration Costs Should Set What You Pay
Antique Guides Editorial 7 May 2026

Damaged antiques look like opportunities and frequently are not. The correct way to price one is to work backwards from what the finished piece would be worth, deduct what the repairs will actually cost, and see what remains. Doing that arithmetic before bidding rather than afterwards prevents most disappointment in this market.

Why does the arithmetic matter so much?

Because restoration is skilled labour charged at professional rates, and it does not scale down with the value of the object. Regluing a chair frame costs the same whether the chair is worth a little or a lot.

On ordinary pieces the work frequently exceeds the finished value, which is why so many damaged antiques sit unsold. The market has already done this calculation, and a piece that looks unaccountably cheap usually is not.

How do you estimate the cost?

By getting a quote before buying rather than after. Restorers and conservators will give an indication from good photographs and a description, and most are happy to do so.

Describe every fault rather than the main one, since a piece needing four repairs costs more than four times a single job would suggest once handling and setup are counted. Ask specifically whether anything might be found once work begins, since concealed problems are common.

Which repairs are cheap?

Regluing loose joints, replacing drawer runners, refitting handles into existing holes, rewiring a lamp, replacing a clock mainspring and servicing a movement. These are routine and predictable.

Reupholstery of a simple drop in seat, replacing a missing glass shade with a correct reproduction, and having silver dents raised are all reasonable. None of these substantially affects value afterwards provided the work is competent and sympathetic.

Which repairs are expensive?

Anything requiring new material to be made by hand. Replacement veneers matched for figure, missing carved elements, cast brass mounts, chandelier drops matched for size and colour, and any component for an early clock or watch movement.

Traditional upholstery on a large piece is many hours of labour plus a substantial quantity of fabric. Cabinet work on a curved or veneered surface is difficult and slow. Get firm quotes on all of these rather than assuming, because estimates frequently surprise people.

Which repairs are not worth doing at all?

Those that reduce value more than the damage does. Refinishing a stripped surface, regilding a period frame, replating old Sheffield plate, repainting a die cast toy and refinishing a watch dial all fall into this category.

In each case the object is worth more damaged and original than repaired and uniform. Before commissioning anything, ask whether the work removes original material, since that is the test collectors apply and it decides what the piece is worth afterwards.

How does condition interact with rarity?

Rarity is what justifies expensive restoration. Where an object is genuinely scarce, buyers accept faults and repairs because the alternative is not owning one, so the work pays for itself.

On common items it does not, since buyers can simply choose an undamaged example. The practical rule is that restoration is worth commissioning on scarce pieces and rarely worth it on ordinary ones, however satisfying the result would be.

What should you check before buying a project?

That everything is present, because missing components are far worse than damaged ones. A broken part can be repaired; a missing one must be made or found.

Count everything: drops, shelves, liners, keys, stoppers, nozzles, spoons and lids. Look for concealed problems by examining the parts nobody finished. Then price the work, add a margin for what will be found, and only then decide what the piece is worth to you.

Should you do the work yourself?

Only if you know what you are doing and the piece is not valuable. Amateur restoration is responsible for an enormous amount of destroyed value, and it is usually obvious to anyone who handles the category.

Cleaning, stripping, sanding, repainting and polishing are the common ways people reduce a piece while trying to improve it. If in doubt, do nothing, because doing nothing is always reversible and almost nothing else is.