Back to Valuations

Why Do Antique Valuations Differ So Widely?

Why Do Antique Valuations Differ So Widely?
Antique Guides Editorial 22 April 2026

Getting two valuations and finding they disagree is unsettling, and it is more common than people expect. Frequently neither is wrong. Understanding what produces the gap tells you whether you are looking at ordinary variation or at something that needs investigating.

What causes most of the difference?

The basis of value, above everything. Replacement cost, open market value and forced sale value are three different questions, and the same object answers each with a very different number.

Before comparing figures, check what basis each used. Two valuations that appear to disagree by a factor of three frequently agree perfectly once you realise one was for insurance and the other for probate.

What about the purpose?

It determines the basis, which is why it must be stated at the outset. A valuation for insurance, for probate, for division of assets and for sale all produce different documents from the same inspection.

A valuer told only that you want to know what something is worth will pick a basis and may not be picking the one you need. Say the purpose plainly when instructing, and check the report states it explicitly.

Do valuers see different things?

Genuinely, yes, particularly outside their own specialism. A furniture specialist may miss a significant mark on a piece of silver, and a generalist may not recognise a scarce variation in a category they rarely handle.

That is the commonest source of a real error rather than an apparent one. Ask both valuers what evidence their figure rests on. If one has noticed something the other did not, the disagreement resolves itself immediately.

How much does market thinness contribute?

Substantially in narrow categories. Where very few examples trade, the available evidence scatters widely and any figure is an interpretation of ambiguous data.

Two valuers reading the same thin set of results can reasonably reach different conclusions. A wide range in such a category is honest rather than evasive, and a valuer offering false precision there is the one to worry about.

Does timing explain gaps?

Sometimes. Valuations separated by several years may both have been correct when made, since values move in both directions and some categories have moved a long way.

Check the dates before comparing. An old valuation is a record of a former market rather than a competing view of the current one, and treating it as current is how people arrive at expectations the market will not meet.

When does a gap indicate a problem?

When the two used the same basis, at the same time, with the same information, and still differ substantially. That points to a genuine disagreement about identification, attribution or condition.

Ask each to explain the reasoning. Usually one has attributed the object differently, or has assessed condition or originality differently, and once that is on the table the gap is resolvable on evidence rather than opinion.

How do you reconcile two figures?

By asking for the comparables behind each. A figure supported by five recent sales of genuinely similar items is stronger than one offered without evidence, however confidently.

Where both are well supported and still differ, the honest answer is a range rather than a point. For probate or division, a jointly instructed valuer whose findings both parties accept in advance avoids the argument entirely.

What should you do with a range?

Accept it as the answer rather than pressing for a single number. Many objects genuinely have a range rather than a price, and a report that says so is more useful than one asserting precision it cannot support.

For insurance, use the upper end, since you need to be able to replace. For probate, use a defensible middle figure supported by evidence. For selling, treat the lower end as your realistic expectation and anything above it as a good result.

Should you tell a second valuer the first figure?

Generally not, at least initially. An opinion reached independently is more useful than one anchored to somebody else's number, and anchoring is a genuine effect even among professionals.

Ask for their assessment first, then discuss the difference once both are on the table. That produces two real opinions rather than one opinion and an echo.