These are the two valuations that carry legal weight, and they deliberately produce different figures for the same object. Confusing them is common and causes genuine difficulty in both directions, because one is designed to replace an item and the other is designed to record what it would actually fetch.
What is a probate valuation?
A probate valuation records the open market value of assets at the date of death, for the purpose of administering an estate and calculating any tax due. Open market value means the price the item would reasonably fetch in a sale between a willing buyer and a willing seller.
In practice that usually means auction value rather than shop value, because that is where household contents are realistically sold. The figures are therefore much lower than owners and families expect, and that lower figure is the correct one for this purpose.
How does insurance value differ?
Insurance uses replacement cost: what you would have to pay to buy an equivalent item from a retail dealer tomorrow. That includes the dealers overheads, margin, and the cost of finding a comparable piece, which can take a long time for anything unusual.
Replacement value is therefore the highest of all the figures attached to an object, frequently several times the probate figure. Neither number is wrong. They answer different questions, and a document that does not state which basis it uses is not fit for either purpose.
Who needs a formal valuation?
Executors administering an estate, particularly where the estate may be liable for tax or where beneficiaries are dividing contents between them. Anyone insuring items of significant value, since insurers require evidence before they will pay a claim.
It is also worth having in a divorce settlement, where contents are being divided, and when gifting valuable items, since records may be needed later. In each case the common feature is that someone other than you will scrutinise the figure.
What must a written valuation contain?
The valuer name and qualifications, the date, the purpose of the valuation, and a clear statement of the basis of value being used. Each item needs a description detailed enough to identify it beyond doubt, including dimensions, materials, marks, and an honest account of condition and any restoration.
Photographs are usual for anything of significance and are extremely useful in a claim. A list of items with a single total and no descriptions is not a valuation and will not satisfy either an insurer or a tax authority.
Can an executor value the contents themselves?
For an ordinary estate with modest household goods, a reasonable estimate made in good faith is generally acceptable, and there is no requirement to employ a professional for everything.
Where there are items of real value, where the estate approaches a tax threshold, or where beneficiaries might dispute the split, a professional valuation protects the executor personally. Executors carry responsibility for the accuracy of the figures they submit, and a professional report shifts that risk considerably.
Why does undervaluing cause problems later?
Because the probate figure sets the base value for later calculations. If an item is entered at a low figure and then sold shortly afterwards for a great deal more, that discrepancy invites questions and may create a liability.
Overvaluing causes the opposite problem, potentially creating a tax charge on value that was never really there. The correct approach is a genuine open market assessment, neither optimistic nor conservative, supported by evidence.
How often should insurance valuations be updated?
Every few years, and after any significant change in the market for what you own. Values move in both directions, and several categories have fallen considerably, which means some collections are now substantially over insured while others are dangerously under insured.
Keep the valuation somewhere other than the house it describes, along with photographs and any receipts. A valuation that burns with the contents it records is of no help at all when the claim is made.