Free valuations are useful and they are not independent, because the person giving the figure would usually like to sell the item and earn commission on it. For anything with legal or financial consequences, you need someone whose only interest is being right. Finding that person takes a little care.
What makes a valuer independent?
That they charge a fee for the opinion and have no stake in what happens to the object afterwards. They do not want to buy it, they do not earn commission if it sells, and their income does not depend on the figure they give.
That distinction matters most in exactly the situations where a valuation carries weight: insurance, probate, division of an estate, divorce settlements and any dispute. A figure from an interested party will not satisfy an insurer or a tax authority, and it may not satisfy the other beneficiaries either.
What qualifications should you look for?
Membership of a recognised professional body covering valuation, which requires demonstrated experience and imposes standards and a complaints procedure. Ask directly which body they belong to and check the membership independently rather than accepting a logo on a website.
Ask about specialism as well. Valuation is broad, and someone whose expertise is furniture may be far weaker on jewellery or clocks. For a mixed house contents, ask how they handle categories outside their own field, since a good valuer will bring in a specialist rather than guess.
How should fees be structured?
A fixed fee or an hourly or daily rate, agreed in writing before work begins. This is the cleaner arrangement and the one to prefer.
Be cautious about a percentage of the total value assessed, which creates an obvious incentive to value high. Ask what the fee covers, whether travel is included, whether there is a minimum charge, and what the total is likely to be. A valuer who will not put the basis of charging in writing is one to avoid.
What should you tell them beforehand?
The purpose of the valuation, because it determines the basis of value used and therefore the entire figure. Insurance requires replacement cost; probate requires open market value on a specific date; a sale valuation is different again.
The same objects produce very different totals under each basis, and a document that does not state which it uses is not fit for any of them. Also tell them about any known provenance, receipts or previous valuations, since these affect the assessment.
What should the report contain?
The valuer name and qualifications, the date, the purpose, and a clear statement of the basis of value. Then each item described in enough detail to identify it beyond doubt, including dimensions, materials, marks, and an honest account of condition and any restoration.
Photographs of anything significant should be included, both for insurance claims and for identification if an item is ever stolen. A list of items with a single total and no descriptions is not a valuation and will not serve when it is tested.
What questions are worth asking?
How long they have valued in this field, whether they carry professional indemnity insurance, how they handle items outside their specialism, and how often they would recommend the valuation is updated.
Ask what happens if you disagree with a figure, and whether they will explain their reasoning. A good valuer will talk you through the comparables behind a number rather than simply asserting it, and that reasoning is frequently more useful to you than the figure itself.
What should make you walk away?
Anyone who offers to value and then buy in the same conversation, particularly if they approached you rather than the other way round. Anyone who pressures you to decide quickly, or who is vague about qualifications and fees.
Never let an item leave your home for assessment without a signed receipt describing it in detail. And be wary of unsolicited approaches offering cash for antiques, which are not valuations in any meaningful sense however they are described.