A valuation is a snapshot of a market on a particular day, and markets move. People commission one, file it, and assume it holds indefinitely. It does not, and the consequences run in two directions: paying premiums on inflated figures, or discovering after a loss that the cover falls well short of what replacement actually costs.
How often is often enough?
Every three to five years for most collections, and sooner where the market for what you own has moved noticeably. Insurers frequently specify an interval themselves in the policy conditions.
Check whether yours does, since failing to comply can affect a claim. For a collection in a fast moving category, more frequent review is sensible. For general household contents that have not changed, a longer interval is defensible.
What has actually happened to values?
They have moved dramatically in both directions over the last generation, which is exactly why review matters. Large furniture, formal tableware and display ceramics have fallen very substantially.
Meanwhile mid century design, studio ceramics, vintage watches, tools and scientific instruments have risen sharply. A valuation from fifteen years ago may be double what some items are worth and half what others now command, within the same document.
What is the risk of over insurance?
Wasted premium, principally. You cannot claim more than an item is worth, so insuring a fallen category at historic values means paying for cover that will never pay out at that level.
This is common and expensive, particularly on inherited collections insured decades ago and never revisited. Reviewing may reduce your premium, which occasionally makes the exercise pay for itself immediately.
What is the risk of under insurance?
More serious. If items have risen and the sum insured has not, you cannot replace what you lose. Worse, many policies contain an averaging clause.
Averaging means that if the total sum insured falls short of the true value, the insurer reduces even a partial claim in the same proportion. So a modest loss on a badly under insured collection pays out at much less than the loss cost, which surprises people at exactly the wrong moment.
When should you review outside the normal cycle?
After acquiring anything significant, after selling or gifting items, after a house move, and whenever you become aware that a category you own has moved sharply.
Also after any restoration, since work can change value in either direction, and after a claim, since the settled position may differ from what you assumed. Tell your insurer about acquisitions as you make them rather than waiting for the next review.
Does the whole collection need revaluing?
Not always. Where only part of a collection has moved, a valuer can update the affected items rather than starting again, which costs considerably less.
Discuss this with the valuer, since a full revaluation of unchanged household contents is frequently unnecessary. What matters is that the specified items, meaning those declared individually above the single article limit, carry current figures.
What should an updated valuation include?
The same elements as any valuation: the valuer name and qualifications, the date, the purpose, the stated basis of value, and each item described in enough detail to identify it beyond doubt.
It should also note what has changed since the previous document, which helps the insurer and helps you understand the movement. Keep the old valuations rather than discarding them, since they build a record of the collection over time and can be useful evidence of ownership.
Where should the document be kept?
Somewhere other than the building it describes, with the photographs, and ideally backed up remotely as well. A valuation that burns with the contents it records is of no assistance at all.
Give a copy to your insurer if they require one, keep one with your important papers, and keep a digital copy accessible from elsewhere. The photographs matter as much as the figures, both for claims and for identifying anything that is later stolen.