The reserve is the least visible and most consequential number in an auction. Buyers never see it, sellers frequently misunderstand it, and getting it wrong is the single most common reason a perfectly good lot fails to sell and then costs its owner money.
What is a reserve?
A confidential minimum price agreed between the seller and the auction house, below which the lot will not be sold. If bidding does not reach it, the lot is bought in, meaning unsold.
It exists to protect the seller from a lot going for very little on a thin day. It is not published, buyers are not told what it is, and the auctioneer is not permitted to sell below it without the vendor agreement.
Who sets it?
The seller, in agreement with the auction house, and it should be recorded in writing in the consignment agreement. In practice the specialist advises and the seller decides.
Most houses will not accept a reserve above the low estimate, because that would make the published estimate misleading to buyers. If you want a higher figure than the specialist thinks achievable, the honest conversation is about whether the estimate itself should change.
Where should it sit?
At or below the low estimate, and ideally at the figure below which you would genuinely rather keep the item than sell it. That is the correct test.
If you would accept less than your reserve when offered it after the sale, the reserve was set wrong. Many sellers discover this when an aftersale offer arrives slightly below their reserve and they take it, having paid fees for an unsold lot in the meantime.
Why does a high reserve backfire?
Because bidding never starts. The auctioneer opens below the low estimate to attract interest, and if the reserve is high the lot has to climb a long way before it can sell at all.
Buyers who sense a lot will not sell disengage. A lot that opens low and attracts several bidders frequently ends higher than one pitched optimistically and knocked down to a single bidder at the reserve, because competition rather than a floor is what drives price.
What does bidding off the wall mean?
The auctioneer taking bids that are not from a real bidder, in order to move the price up towards the reserve. It is a normal and permitted practice up to the reserve figure.
Above the reserve it is not permitted, since the lot can then be sold and every bid must be genuine. Understanding this explains why the early bidding on some lots seems to come from nowhere, and why it stops at a certain point.
What happens if a lot fails?
It is bought in and remains yours. Many houses charge a fee on unsold lots, and photography, lotting and insurance charges may have been incurred regardless.
Read the consignment terms and ask specifically what you owe if the lot does not sell. Storage charges frequently begin once a free collection period expires. A house that charges nothing on unsold lots is offering a genuinely better deal than the headline commission suggests.
Should you ever sell without a reserve?
Sometimes, and it is worth considering for lower value material. A no reserve lot attracts bidders who might otherwise not engage, and it frequently produces stronger competition.
The risk is obvious: it will sell for whatever it makes, which can be very little on a quiet day. It suits items where the downside is small and the aim is to clear rather than to maximise. Catalogues normally state when a lot is offered without reserve.
What should you do if a lot is bought in?
Consider any aftersale offer seriously rather than dismissing it, since a bid slightly below your reserve from somebody who has seen the item is real evidence of value.
If you re enter it, change something: lower the reserve, improve the photography, move it to a specialist sale, or wait long enough that the market has turned over. Re offering the same lot at the same reserve in the next sale rarely produces a different outcome.