Philately rewards precision more than almost any other collecting field, because two stamps that appear identical across a room can differ enormously in value. The features that separate them are measurable rather than aesthetic, and checking them requires very little equipment and a careful hand.
What is a watermark and why does it matter?
A deliberate thinning of the paper during manufacture, forming a design visible when the paper is held to light. Postal authorities used watermarks as a security measure, and they changed the design periodically.
That makes the watermark a dating and identification feature. The same stamp design printed on paper with two different watermarks constitutes two distinct issues, sometimes with a large difference in scarcity. Catalogues list them separately for exactly this reason.
How do you check a watermark safely?
Start with the simplest method. Hold the stamp up to a strong light and look through it, or place it face down on a black surface and view it at an angle. Many watermarks are visible this way with no equipment at all.
If that fails, a watermark detector tray with a proprietary fluid makes the design appear briefly. Use only fluid sold for the purpose, never water and never household solvents, both of which can damage gum, ink and paper permanently. Test on a common stamp first, and never immerse a mint stamp with original gum.
What is a perforation gauge?
A measurement of how many perforation holes fall within a fixed distance along an edge. Different printings used different perforating machines, so the gauge distinguishes issues that are otherwise identical.
A perforation gauge is an inexpensive card or plastic scale. Lay the stamp on it and slide until the holes align exactly with a row of dots. Measure every side, because stamps can be perforated differently on horizontal and vertical edges, and that combination is itself an identifying feature.
What else identifies a printing?
The method of printing, visible under magnification. Line engraved printing leaves ink standing very slightly proud of the paper, which you can sometimes feel as well as see. Surface printing lies flat. Photogravure shows a fine screen pattern of dots.
Plate numbers and control letters printed in the margins of sheets identify which plate produced a stamp, and on some issues these are genuinely valuable. Shades of colour matter too, and catalogues list distinct shades separately, though colour is the hardest feature to judge and is best compared against a known reference example.
How is condition assessed?
Ruthlessly. Centring, meaning how evenly the design sits within the perforations, is a major factor, and a well centred example commands a substantial premium over a poorly centred one.
Check for thins, which are patches where paper has been pulled away from the back, usually by careless removal from an album. Hold the stamp to light and look for pale areas. Check that all perforation teeth are present, look for creases, and on mint stamps assess whether the gum is original and undisturbed, since a hinge mark reduces value considerably.
How should stamps be handled and stored?
With tongs, never fingers, because skin oils stain paper over time and the damage is permanent. Tongs with rounded flat tips are designed not to cut the paper.
Store in albums with acid free pages or in stock books with proper strips, away from light and damp. Never use ordinary adhesive tape or glue anywhere near a stamp. Modern mounts that enclose the stamp entirely are preferable to hinges for anything of value, since hinges disturb gum.
What makes postcards valuable?
Usually the subject rather than the stamp. Cards showing identifiable streets, shopfronts, railway stations, disasters, local events and social history attract collectors of those subjects, and a photographic card of a small village can be worth far more than a general scenic view.
The message and postmark add interest and can add value, particularly where they record a datable event. Condition matters as with any paper item: creases, corner damage, album marks and fading all reduce value, and cards should be stored upright in sleeves rather than stacked loose in boxes.